Do AI Content Detectors Work? A Complete Review

AI is everywhere. There’s a high possibility that an AI bot is already creating the emails you're replying to, the social media updates you're scrolling through, and the websites you're visiting.

You’d think that AI’s ever-present nature today has made the role of an AI content detector a necessity. However, Google’s insistence on high-quality content regardless of its source (AI or human) has made the presence of these AI content detection tools insignificant for SEO purposes.

That said, if you wish to learn how to detect AI generated content and how the most popular AI content detectors work, this blog post is for you!

     

Introduction to AI Content Detectors

The AI revolution has led to many businesses choosing AI-generated content for their online presence across various platforms, making it hard to moderate this sheer volume manually.

It has prompted the question, “how to detect AI generated content?”

You might think that the answer lies in AI content detectors.

However, now that it’s evident Google does not care about where you produce your content from, as long as it presents E-E-A-T or experience, expertise, authoritativeness, and trustworthiness, enterprises don’t need to worry about detecting the use of AI content. All they need to think about is creating high-quality content. So, you don’t need AI content detectors after all.

That said, an AI content detector recognizes common indicators that might reveal if the content is written by AI or if it’s human-generated. It uses markers that often include patterns such as a robotic writing style or excessive use of specialized vocabulary.

Typically, such tools focus on widely recognized AI text generators, which include but are not limited to ChatGPT, Google Bard, and Jasper. Moreover, certain detectors can be customized to address specific scenarios, such as identifying AI-generated content in college essays.

However, these tools still need a lot of work to become fully reliable as they tend to generate false results, especially when it comes to detecting human content as AI. Time and again, they have falsely detected well-written human-generated content as AI content, which brings into question their validity.

How can businesses, entrepreneurs, and individuals entrust an AI content detector to be reliable when it cannot fully differentiate between well-written human and AI content?

Understanding How AI Detection Tools Work

AI detection tools work somewhat like how Google predicts words. They use a language model to guess if certain words or phrases will appear in the content. Then, they provide a score to show how similar the content is to what a human might write, according to Google.

The primary utility of these tools lies in assisting website owners who utilize AI writers to generate a large volume of content. By employing AI content detectors, these site owners can gauge the "human-like" quality of their content, thus mitigating the risk of potential Google penalties.

To sum it up, AI detector tools can be a valuable resource for maintaining content quality while harnessing the efficiency of AI-generated content production. However, these tools can only work if they can be trusted to generate accurate results.

Complete Review: 8 Most Popular AI Content Detectors

Originality AI

 

Originality AI stands out as among the top AI detectors on the market. Its primary function is to scan text and look for AI-generated content and plagiarism, making it an invaluable asset for content creators and educators.

With impressive accuracy rates, it excels at identifying AI-generated text, having an accuracy of 94% on GPT-3 and 3.5 content and even reaching 99% accuracy with GPT-4, but falls short when detecting human-written content. Additionally, it achieves a commendable accuracy of 94.5% when detecting paraphrased content.

Top Features

• Team management capabilities
• Offers a wide range of AI writing tools

Pricing

Originality AI's pricing is competitive, charging $0.01 for 100 words, with various credit packages available to suit different needs.

Pros

• Top-notch customer support
• High accuracy when detecting AI content
• Convenient Chrome extension

Cons

• Misinterprets human writing as AI
• No free trials
• Exclusive support for only English content

Final Verdict

Originality AI excels in AI content detection. However, it frequently classifies human content as AI-generated, which brings into question its reliability. The tool works for content creators but is not a reliable option for large-scale organizations.

Winston AI

 

Winston AI has proved to be an indispensable tool tailored for writers, web publishers, and academic members seeking to identify AI-generated content accurately. Notably, Winston AI goes beyond text-based content, as it supports Optical Character Recognition (OCR) technology, allowing its users to effectively scan image files for AI-generated content effortlessly.

Top Features

• Optical Character Recognition (OCR) Technology
• Intuitive and user-friendly interface
• Real-time prompt results

Pricing

• Free Plan: Offers 2,000 words of scanning or a one-week trial
• Essential Plan: Priced at $12/month (annually) or $18/month (monthly) for scanning 80,000 words monthly
• Advanced Plan: Priced at $19/month (annually) or $29/month (monthly) for scanning 200,000 words monthly
• Custom Plans: Tailored solutions available upon request through Winston AI's sales team

Pros

• Offers human, plagiarism, and readability scores
• Supports various formats, including .docx, .png, and .jpg
• Multilingual support for English and French content

Cons

• Users must signup to use it
• URL scan not available
• The free version does not offer plagiarism detection

Final Verdict

Winston AI offers a user-friendly AI content detection solution with its OCR capability and affordability. However, it has limitations in the free plan and it often misinterprets human content.

Copyleaks

 

Copyleaks is a cutting-edge AI and plagiarism detection software designed to cater to individuals, educators, and businesses seeking to identify AI-generated content accurately. With an impressive reported accuracy rate of 99.12%, Copyleaks is a top contender in the category.

Pricing

Copyleaks offers various pricing plans, including a free option for limited usage. Their paid plans include the Essential plan at $9.99/month, the Business plan at $19.99/month, and a Custom plan tailored to specific needs.

Top Features

• Multilingual support(English, Portuguese, Spanish, German, and French)
• Seamless integration with Learning Management Systems (LMS)
• Plagiarism detection capabilities via source code
• OCR technology for image-based content scanning
• Compatibility with a wide range of language models

Pros

• Offers a white-label option for customization
• Facilitates integration of API into enterprise Systems
• Chrome extension is available

Cons

• Users need to hover over their text to access percentage scores
• Occasional false positives, though rare

Final Verdict

A handy tool to detect AI content. However results are not 100% accurate. Other drawbacks include the need to hover for percentage scores and occasional false positives.

Sapling.ai

 

Sapling.ai was developed by a group of former researchers from esteemed institutions such as Berkeley University of California, Stanford, and Google. This multipurpose tool offers grammar checking, punctuation validation, sentence rewriting, and AI content detection.

Sapling.ai specializes in detecting content produced by leading AI models, showcasing an impressive 97% accuracy rate. It efficiently quantifies the percentage of AI content within a given content and highlights it in red, ensuring precision and ease of use.

Pricing

• Free Plan: No cost, providing access to essential features
• Pro Plan: Priced at $25/month, delivering advanced capabilities
• Enterprise Plan: Customized quotes available for tailored solutions

Top Features

• Robust AI detection
• High accuracy rating of 97%
• Time-saving features such as auto-complete, chat assistance, and snippets
• Seamlesslyintegrates with third-party applications such as Salesforce, HubSpot, Pipedrive, and Jira

Pros

• A great free plan for users to explore essential functionalities
• Swift text analysis, catering to content 50 words and above

Cons

• Occasional false positives
• Lacks built-in plagiarism checking capabilities

Final Verdict

Sapling.ai stands as a versatile AI tool catering to the needs of agencies and customer-facing teams. However, false positive results appear frequently, indicating that content authenticity could be compromised.

GPTZero

 

GPTZero, the brainchild of Princeton University student Edward Tian, introduces a unique classification model tailored to assist educators in predicting and detecting AI-generated text.

This innovative tool leverages perplexity, a measure of text randomness and burstiness, gauging content predictability based on patterns, to analyze text effectively. Its training, focused on English prose, encompasses a diverse range of human-written and AI-generated texts, ensuring robust performance.

Pricing

• GPTZero Classic: Free, up to 5,000 characters per document, three files per batch upload
• GPTZero Educator: $9.99/month, up to 50,000 characters per document, unlimited batch uploads, 1 million words/month
• GPTZero Pro: $19.99/month, up to 50,000 characters per document, unlimited batch uploads, 2 million words/month

 

Top Features

• Streamlined batch file uploading for efficiency
• Supports ChatGPT, GPT-3, GPT-2, and LLaMA
• Uses perplexity scores
• Minimum requirement of 250 characters for analysis

Pros

• Effective detection of AI-generated text
• Offers a free plan
• Supports many file types, including PDF, docx, and Txt

Cons

• Occasional false negatives, though infrequent
• Presentation of scores may be confusing for some users

Final Verdict  

GPTZero is helpful as a free tool offering quick AI-content detection. However, the results are not 100% accurate. The tool also misreads AI as human and vice versa.

Content at Scale AI Detector

 

Content at Scale AI Detector is an ideal choice for content marketers and academics. This free AI detection tool specializes in identifying content generated by ChatGPT, GPT-3, and other prominent AI models. Notably, Content at Scale also offers content generation capabilities, making it versatile for crafting long-form content exceeding 2,000 words.

Pricing

Content at Scale AI Detector is available for free.

Top Features

• Detection capabilities for GPT-2, GPT-3, GPT-3.5, and ChatGPT
• Versatility in scanning various types of text, including SEO, educational, marketing, and academic content
• API access is available upon request
• Supports text scanning up to 25,000 characters
• Multilingual support enhances usability

Pros

• User-friendly interface for easy navigation
• Effective highlighting of AI-generated text
• Scanning starts from just 25 words
• Offers additional content optimization services

Cons

• Occasional false negatives, particularly with long-form content
• Room for improvement in detection capabilities

Final Verdict   

Content at Scale AI Detector proves to be an essential tool, offering ease of use, basic AI detection, and added content generation capabilities—all without costing a dime. However, it can falsely highlight human-written content as AI.

GLTR

 

GLTR, or the Giant Language Model Test Room, is an invaluable free AI text detection tool developed through the collaborative efforts of MIT-IBM Watson AI lab and HarvardNLP. Specifically honed to detect text generated by the GPT2 NLP model, GLTR grants users access to the publicly available GPT2 model from OpenAI.

GLTR analyzes input text by assessing the probability of each word compared to what GPT-2 would generate. It then presents the results by highlighting words in green, yellow, or red, representing the lowest to highest likelihood of AI generation. If red words outweigh green ones, it signals potential AI-generated content.

Pricing

GLTR is available free to use.

Top Features

• Tailored for precise detection of GPT2-generated text
• Intuitive text highlighting to distinguish AI-generated and human-written content
• Facilitates forensic analysis of language model text inputs
• Open-source software readily accessible on GitHub

Pros

• Exceptional accuracy in detecting GPT2-generated text
• Visual feedback aids in quick identification

Cons

• Complex user interface
• Limited to detecting content generated by the GPT2 NLP model

Final Verdict   

GLTR excels as an exceptional GPT2 text detection tool, but the tool misses the mark when it comes to advanced AI-generated content.

ZeroGPT

 

ZeroGPT stands out as one of the most widely used and free AI text detectors available today. This distinct tool, often confused with GPTZero, is an AI company offering a diverse array of AI solutions, including direct interaction with ChatGPT via Telegram or WhatsApp.

ZeroGPT employs cutting-edge DeepAnalyse™ Technology to ascertain the origins of the text. Developed through the analysis of millions of articles and texts encompassing both AI-generated and human-written content, the result is the highly precise ZeroGPT algorithm, boasting a remarkable 98% accuracy rate in detecting text sources.

Pricing

ZeroGPT is completely free to use, with the option for private API access available upon email request.

Top Features

• Detects text generated by GPT-4
• Achieves an impressive 98% accuracy in AI content detection
• Multilingual capabilities cater to diverse language needs
• Provides access to a range of other AI tools
• Completely free for user convenience

Pros

• Utilizes DeepAnalyse technology for AI content detection
• Detects AI-generated text across multiple languages
• Allows citation for AI text detection

Cons

• Occasionally yields false results when detecting human-generated content
• Lacks plagiarism detection capabilities

Final Verdict

ZeroGPT is readily available for everyone and offers multilingual support. While the tool can sufficiently detect AI content, it often fails to distinguish human-generated content and gives inaccurate results.

The Bottom Line: Do AI Content Detectors Actually Work?

 

If we look at the bigger picture, the answer is ‘No’. While the above-listed tools may be able to distinguish between AI-generated and human-written text, a lingering question surrounds their accuracy and reliability.

One of the biggest shortcomings of these content detector tools is their tendency to frequently misclassify human writing as AI-generated. In particular, the challenge lies in identifying human writing that is so perfect that it mimics AI-generated content, blurring the lines between the two. Originality AI is considered the worst in this regard as it happens to be a repeat offender by highlighting human-written content as AI-generated content.

In light of these limitations, it becomes evident that while AI content detectors offer some degree of assistance in various aspects of content analysis, they are not the benchmark when it comes to distinguishing between human and AI content.

Therefore, it is essential to approach content assessment with a nuanced perspective, acknowledging the limitations of AI and emphasizing human oversight to ensure content integrity and authenticity in an ever-evolving digital landscape.

Experience the CDP Difference: Your Content Partner for Success!

At Content Development Pros (CDP), we understand the crucial role that original and authentic content plays in establishing credibility and exclusivity. Our content writing team combines creative flair with SEO expertise to ensure that your content not only engages your audience but also performs well.

Our content writing services include:

• Blog Posts
• Articles
• Web Content
• SEO
• Social Media Content
• Ebook
• Product Descriptions
• Guest Blogging
• Website Management
• Newsletters
• Emails
• Business Plans
• Presentations
• Business Proposals
• Online Press Release
• Statement of Purpose
• Recommendation Letters
• Speech
• Biography